Some commentators are calling this the war most widely supported in Israel since 1967. Surveys find over 90 percent of the public supporting Israel's operations. In response to the call up of reserves, some units report more than 100 percent coming to duty. Those not called want to join the fight. Yossi Beilin, the leader of the left of center Meretz and co-author of the dizzy Geneva initiative (claimed to be the way of making peace with the Palestinians), is saying that the war is justified; and, indeed, it would be appropriate to attack the source of Hezbollah weaponry in Syria.
Support is not assured over the long run. Looking back to the great war of 1967, not a few Israelis came to the view that holding the West Bank and Gaza, and the placement of Jewish settlements, were a national disaster. For the time being, however, the public is with the army and the government.
Ha'aretz is arguably the best newspaper in the country, but without a doubt the most leftist of the major papers. Yesterday its staff and especially its headline writers could not resist their inner drives. The big headline on page one was "Rice: prevent a humanitarian disaster." (Most other coverage indicated that Rice's prime concern was that Israel should continue its attacks against Hezbollah.) Other page one headlines were snappier in Hebrew than these formulations meant to convey their meaning:
*High incidence of Israeli casualties revealed
*Olmert is not a partner (the thrust of the article was that Syria was not a partner)
*Limited time for the military operation until politics intervenes
*Lebanese family injured by a missile while seeking safety
*Rabbi says that it is forbidden for population to remain in Haifa
*Rumors that Metulah will be evacuated (subsequently shown to be false)
Also in abundance are commentators from the ranks of retired military persons, journalists, and undistinguished others who are speaking out in criticism of one or another detail of what the military or the government has done or failed to do, or did too much of or not enough of. The Washington Post has an article focusing on the wide spread support of the operation in Israel, but also reports that a "make up artist and stylist" from Jerusalem saidthat since the fighting is still going on the Hezbollah must have a better army than Israel.
The IDF continues to destroy pieces of Lebanon. The chief of the general staff is quoted as ordering 10 structures in Beirut to be destroyed for every missile fired into Haifa. Ground forces are moving slowly through villages in southern Lebanon. It is not cheap in terms of Israeli casualties, but the outcome is not optimistic for Hezbollah. No matter how well armed and disciplined, the 5,000-10,000 fighters cannot hold out against the tanks, artillery, air power, and many more soldiers of the IDF. Israeli willpower is important, but the signs from opinion polls and reservists suggest that willpower is great enough.
Characteristically, international pressure has caused Israel to limit its military operations. In this case, the clear responsibility of Hezbollah for initiating the conflict and Hamas doing the same on the southern front, along with Hezbollah and Hamas aiming missiles at civilian targets provides a buffer against the concern for Lebanese civilians. Even the French foreign minister says that it will be necessary to disarm Hezbollah even while he calls Israel's response disproportionate. And the U.N. official who came to examine humanitarian issues accused Israel of violating unspecified humanitarian law, but also said that Hezbollah was responsible: both for attacking Israel and cowering with its weapons and fighters in civilian neighborhoods.
Uncle George is our biggest hero, as he is doing his best to keep the world off Israel's back. And why not? The IDF is doing his work. This has become a major front in Bush's war against international terror. Hezbollah and Hamas are in the same category as al-Qaeda. Hezbollah's Hassan Nasrallah and Hamas Khaled Mashal are minor league versions of Osama bin Laden. Israel is doing so much for the United States that it seemed necessary for a senior IDF officer to assert that Israel was not the puppet or servant of any other country, and that it was pursuing its own national interests.
I note that on some websites, such as congress.org that support for Israel is 43% vs. 57% against support of Israel. Furthermore, I found that the American-Arab Anti-Discrimination Committee, ADC, is activating it's supporters to schedule meetings with their congressional representatives who will be on break in their home districts beginning the 28th of July. Of course, they oppose support of Israel. Even my own synagogue lobbies for "peace". I will be actively lobbying too, but for the right of Israel to exist, and defend itself.
Posted by: Kathleen Hartson on July 26, 2006 08:08 AMSo long as rockets continue to rain on Israel, the international community can only lament the Israeli defense as being disproportionate. They will not effectively thwart the Iraeli defense until the missles run out. Even then, I believe that "Uncle George" will support unlimited military operations most likely up to the Litani River. There is a truth to your statement that Israel is the front line against terrorism. I am pretty sure that Bush understands this. We are blessed that Bush does not care about popularity ratings. Despite record low ratings, he will not stop in the fight against terrorism.
Wikipedia has a very good account of the "2006 Israeli-Lebanon conflict". I recall that you were searching for an appropriate name to this war. The wikipedia name for this war is too non-descriptive, although their account of the conflict is thorough in almost all aspects. I would suggest "The Umbrella War" or "The Shadow War". There are several meanings that are appropriately conveyed by using these terms. One obvious meaning is that the war intends to stop the rain of rockets. Umbrella comes from the Latin term "umbra" for shade and shadow. The Hezbollah enemy can be said to be the shadow of Iran and Syria cast over the region. Finally there is significance to the term "shadow" in the book of Psalms.
Right now I am listening to artillery training at Fort Lewis (about 45 miles north of Olympia, WA). I tell people it is "the sound of freedom". It is very loud for being so far away. My 19 month old daughter loves the booms. I know the U.S. has been blessed with strong leaders who know how to fight and win wars. However, I don't believe in "good" wars, but rather "necessary" wars. Israel has a history of fighting necessary wars that are both decisive and quick. This history may create unreasonable expectations that Israel will finish this within a couple weeks. It is most definitely a necessary war. I just hope it is over soon. A belabored war is always bad for everyone.
Tim
Posted by: Tim on July 26, 2006 09:11 PMIra, I am not a historian or military strategist and I don't even know if people in power are thinking this.
Iran is the bad guy. They have hijacked the Muslim faith for their secular gain. They have plenty of money. They want to destroy Israel and conquer the midEast.. etc. etc.
But, from a geographical standpoint, I have been thinking for several years now, on first it was Afghanistan and then Iraq. These two battles isolated Iran (yes, I know Iran is causing the problems in Iraq by supplying arms and money to the Iraqi mafioso- aka Sadrists and others) a little bit. At the least, it made ground travel between Iran and Syria more difficult.
Syria has to watch itself (at least till Iran has long range missles and nukes) at this moment because they are vulnerable without the ability of Iran to run lots of troops through Iraq.
And, I have been seeing and hearing more and more recognition that Syria and Iran have a big hand in this situation. That is not good for Hezbollah.
The bombing of the UN house in southern Lebanon is now getting press that, while it was a UN house, the UN let Hezbollah use it as a safe house.
I know things are dark now, but when this is over, I see a little better future for Israel.
Posted by: swatter on July 27, 2006 07:35 AM