Of course Michael Moore hates America. And as I pointed out yesterday, he also hates Israel. But in all fairness, I don't think Moore discriminates against Israel and America. He is an equal opportunity hater. He hates everybody.
"Combustible Boy" of the mothballed Sound and Fury blog sent me some snapshots of pages from Moore's 1997 book Downsize This. Here are pages 88-89 and 90-91 from chapter 10 "Germany Still Hasn't Paid for Its Sins and I Intend to Collect". After starting out by saying that Germany didn't do enough to compensate the world for the Holocaust, he launches into a thoroughly insane bit of historical analysis:
I know some of you are saying, "Hey, Mike, the survivors got to move to Israel after the war. Didn't giving them that land make it up to them?" Well, I don't think Israel was actually "given" to them. The British were ruling the place (then called Palestine), and suddenly all these Holocaust survivors with nowhere else to go started arriving and the Brits didn't like that one bit. But they didn't have the energy to fight the Jewish guerrillas after having just lost most of their British empire. so they just bagged the place and said, "Fine, you want this, it's yours." Most Arab residents were not considered in the deal.Then he froths at the mouth about the many Germans who have emigrated to Florida, or who simply visit the state:
I have never understood why giving the Holocaust survivors Palestine/Israel was such a great gift. Have you ever been there? It's a friggin' desert! There's nothing there! Israelis like to tell you, "We've made the desert bloom!" Talk about rationalizing something ... I'm telling you, it's 100 percent sand, rock, and more sand. Why did we think we were making it up to them by placing them in a horrible environment that has cost them even more lives in more wars? Because the Bible said so? When did the world start going by *that* book?
If we had really wanted to do what was right -- and punish the Germans -- we should have given the survivors the state of Bavaria. Now, that's one beautiful piece of real estate! And it would have cost the Germans plenty. Turning Palestine into Israel didn't hurt the Germans one single bit. But losing Bavaria to the Jews would have really kicked those bastards where it counted. Israel has only 10,840 square miles; Bavaria has over 28,000! Israel has few, if any, natural resources; Bavaria is rich in minerals, forests, and water. Since the war, the Israelis have been surrounded by hostile enemies who want them dead; Bavaria is surrounded by the beautiful Alps containing a few goats and those three guys in the Ricola commercial. I guess it's probably too late to correct this mistake by moving Tel Aviv to Munich and forcing the Germans to go and try to make the desert bloom.
I am of two minds regarding this German invasion of Florida. On the one hand, I hate Florida. It's full of bugs, humidity, and stupid people running around with guns. And it's got those nutty Cuban exiles. If there were a pair of scissors big enough, I wish we could just snip the state where it hangs off the rest of the country.For those who don't yet realize that Fahrenheit 9/11 is little more than Michael Moore's private pathological delusion, the above passages from Downsize This should put everything in perspective.There is part of me that likes the fact that all these ex-Nazis are moving there to terrorize the people of Florida. Serves them right. The Right-Wing Cubans versus the Geriatric SS in a fight to the finish! I'd pay money to watch that one on Pay-Per-View.
Michael Moore was the personal guest of Jimmy and Rosalyn Carter at this year's Democratic Convention.
Posted by Stefan Sharkansky at August 08, 2004 05:00 PMMichael Moore strikes me as a miserable, self-loathing misanthrope. I'd almost feel sorry for him if he didn't project his hatred and bitterness at other people.
Posted by: Matt J Kurlander on August 9, 2004 05:45 AMI'll never figure out why people think this guy is funny. I honestly tried to watch Bowling for Columbine, but the smarmy, sarcastic narrative was like a fingernail on the blackboard. A third rate stand-up on Comedy Central has better timing and material.
Posted by: Ray Zacek on August 9, 2004 09:31 AMWhat's funny is that I've heard at least two interviews on German radio the past few weeks where Moore has said how much he _loves_ Germans and Germany for buying his books... er, I mean for opposing Bush and the Iraq war.
Posted by: Scott on August 9, 2004 10:56 AMI can't tell if Moore is being sarcastic or serious in those passages. If he's being sarcastic, it's pretty acidic sarcasm. If he's serious, then it's just pathetically sad.
Posted by: Steve B. on August 9, 2004 11:09 AMOne thing missing from Moore's assessment of Florida: it's part of the US (you know, his own nation) and populated by US citizens (you know, his own countrymen). Who, according to some extreme readings of the US Constitution, are entitled to vote and express opinions and own property and all that other stuff real Americans like Moore so treasure.
Well, if people are psychotic enough to think that they can be Americans and at the same time disagree with Michael Moore, then I pity them their foolishness and can only regard it as unfortunate that the Constitution does not have provisions for disenfranchising and deporting them.
Obviously the founding fathers, rationalists that they were, never seriously considered the possibility that anyone would not agree with Moore.
Posted by: Steve Skubinna on August 9, 2004 11:25 AMScott - Nobody bothers to hold Moore responsible for being consistent. Heck, at the end of the foreword to that same book from 1997 that Stefan quotes, Moore says that he hates guns. Something like three years later, he was making "Bowling for Columbine", where we're expected to believe that he likes guns just fine and that he joined the NRA for that reason, or something. And Moore fans take his word for it, and will repeat it back to anyone who calls "Bowling for Columbine" an anti-gun piece.
Posted by: Combustible Boy on August 9, 2004 12:31 PM"those nutty Cuban exiles"
Sheiss-kopf.
Posted by: Bleeding heart conservative on August 9, 2004 07:22 PMWhen all else fails, blame the messenger...
Posted by: Rabii LNMB on August 12, 2004 12:26 PM