An Israeli correspondent e-mails:
Reading the weekend papers, I once again read that Israel is accused by Palestinian groups of being in breach of the hudna [e.g.here -- Ed]. The concept is a bit strange to me. If the hudna was declared unilaterally and without conditions by the Palestinians, to further their own interests, how can Israel be in breach of it?Posted by Stefan Sharkansky at August 09, 2003 01:49 PM
And if we make that leap of logic, how well are the Palestinians sticking to it? One need not quote the daily list of violence. It is enough to ask the US State Department. Friday's Hebrew press reported that the State Department has refused to lift its travel advisory on Israel. Clearly the US does not think that the Palestinian implementation of the hudna is adequate. Just as the Roadmap is measured by actions - so should US assessments.
Although the issue is security and safety, there is further signifance in the State Department travel advisories. As long as they are in place, US travellers to Israel are unable to get adequate travel insurance. That not only is a huge problem for Israel's tourist industry, but also severly depressses the business sector, as a local visit is critical to closing many potential deals.
So when you see Americans pressing Israel for some sort of reciprocity for Palestinian concessions, remind them that not only are the concessions far less than the Roadmap requirements, but that the US State Department is not willing to risk a short stay by its citizens. Should we take greater risks?
Hmmm... Unfortunately I cannot remember where I read it, but I seem to recall that "hudna" is not a cease fire, but more akin to a "retreat and regroup" tactic.
Posted by: RedLion on August 10, 2003 11:42 AMOf course it's a regrouping tactic.
The war goes on...until until both sides recognize that the term "victory" is meaningless and nobody is going to be moving anywhere else, and follow up this recognition with a willingness to accept a share of moral responsiblity for what the other side has suffered.
Posted by: Markus Rose on August 11, 2003 09:25 AM